May 6, 2025 12:57 am
Full News

Indonesia’s $10 Billion Deal with China Raises Sovereignty Concerns and ASEAN Tensions

A $10 billion deal between Indonesia and China, finalized this week, has sparked concerns among maritime security and international law experts. Critics warn the agreement could undermine Indonesia’s sovereignty in the North Natuna Sea, exacerbate illegal fishing, and increase political tensions within the ASEAN bloc.

“Indonesia risks economic subjugation by China, potentially paving the way for increased military influence in the South China Sea,” said Merisa Dwi Juanita, founder of Bara Maritim, an independent maritime security research institution.

Diplomatic Outreach in Beijing

Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto, recently inaugurated, embarked on his first official foreign visit to China on November 8. During high-level talks with Chinese President Xi Jinping in Beijing, both leaders emphasized their commitment to strengthening bilateral ties.

“We aim to enhance this relationship for the mutual benefit of our peoples and the prosperity, peace, and stability of Asia,” Prabowo stated.

However, the joint statement following the visit has alarmed analysts. Experts suggest it marks a shift in Indonesia’s stance on the South China Sea, implicitly acknowledging China’s controversial “nine-dash line” territorial claims. This could provoke reactions from ASEAN neighbors, including the Philippines, Malaysia, Brunei, and Vietnam, who also have overlapping claims in the region.

The $10 Billion Agreement

The business forum in Beijing facilitated agreements between Indonesian and Chinese firms worth approximately $10 billion. The deals focus on fisheries, oil and gas exploration, maritime safety, and sustainable mineral extraction.

Critics argue that these agreements could inadvertently validate China’s claims in waters falling within Indonesia’s Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). Aristyo Darmawan, an international law professor at Universitas Indonesia, described the deal as a “concession of sovereign rights” to China, violating international law as outlined in the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).

“Since 2017, China has proposed joint development projects in disputed areas. Indonesia’s participation could weaken its position on sovereignty and territorial rights,” Darmawan wrote in an op-ed.

Indonesia officially rejects China’s claim to the waters around Natuna Island, which lies within its EEZ but is included in China’s nine-dash line.

Concerns Over Illegal Fishing

Merisa Dwi Juanita also expressed concerns over the potential rise in illegal, unreported, and unregulated (IUU) fishing by Chinese vessels.

“Indonesia’s overlapping claims narrative complicates law enforcement and could exacerbate losses for local fishermen,” she warned, calling for stronger maritime defenses and better protection for local fishing communities against aggressive actions by China’s coast guard.

Regional and Legal Implications

The Indonesian Foreign Ministry maintains that the agreement aligns with the 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea, which promotes peaceful cooperation. It insists the deal does not validate China’s nine-dash line claim and respects Indonesia’s sovereignty in the North Natuna Sea.

However, analysts argue the agreement may deepen disunity within ASEAN, particularly as it contrasts with a 2022 Indonesia-Vietnam EEZ agreement that took over a decade to negotiate. Critics warn that the partnership with China could delay ratification of such agreements and disrupt regional solidarity in negotiations with Beijing.

Darmawan described the deal as a strategic win for China, potentially eroding Indonesia’s sovereign rights by transferring decision-making to a joint committee. He urged Jakarta to independently develop the Natuna Islands rather than engaging in joint ventures with Beijing.

While Indonesia sees the cooperation as a step toward regional stability, questions remain about its long-term impact on national sovereignty and ASEAN unity.

Related News
What Happened in Bangladesh? From Dhanmondi to Ishwardi: Destruction and the Bleeding Heart of Bengalis
Power Outage Shuts Down Heathrow Airport; 120 Flights Diverted
Progress in Gaza peace talks, but no agreement yet
Hayley Atwell to Return to Avengers with a Twist
Jury to Hear Opening Statements in Salman Rushdie Attack Trial
Tensions Escalate as Pakistan Warns of Imminent Indian Military Action
Related Posts
Russia-Ukraine Ceasefire Possible “At Any Moment
Pakistan Accuses India of Violating Indus Waters Treaty, Prepares Formal Notice
India Suspends Indus Water Treaty Amid Rising Tensions with Pakistan
Myanmar Junta May Weaponize Nuclear Power Plant, Warns UN Envoy
India-Pakistan Tensions Escalate Following Pahalgam Attack
Trump Announces 100% Tariff on All Foreign Films
More News

Baloch Liberation Army Claims Responsibility for Coordinated Attacks in Balochistan

Balochistan, Pakistan – April 19, 2025: The Baloch Liberation Army (BLA) has claimed responsibility for a series of coordinated attacks across multiple districts in Balochistan, targeting Pakistani security forces. The group described these operations as retaliation against the military’s presence and intelligence activities in the region.In a statement, the BLA detailed four separate incidents. The […]

Bangladesh Orders Commission to Investigate 2009 Paramilitary Mutiny

DHAKA – Bangladesh has established a commission to investigate the failed 2009 paramilitary mutiny and subsequent crackdown, including the role of alleged foreign backers, according to inquiry chief A L M Fazlur Rahman. The mutiny began in February 2009 when soldiers from the Bangladesh Rifles (BDR) paramilitary force stole thousands of weapons from their headquarters […]

“I will never forget for sure”

Spider-Man’s Martin Starr to Appear in ’90s Thriller RemakeMartin Starr, known for his role in the Spider-Man franchise, is set to join the cast of the upcoming remake of the 1992 thriller The Hand That Rocks the Cradle. The original film, which starred Rebecca De Mornay as the vengeful Mrs. Mott, follows a widow whose […]

We are grateful for the support of the Indian Army and people in our War of Liberation.

The Victory Day celebrations were held at Fort William in Kolkata. The leader of the Bangladesh delegation said, “We are grateful for the support and military support that the Indian Army and the Indian people gave us during the great liberation war of Bangladesh.” ” Victory Day celebrations are held at Fort William on December […]

10 Mosques in India to be Covered Before Holi to Maintain Peace

To prevent any unrest during the Holi festival, authorities in India have planned to cover 10 mosques in Uttar Pradesh’s Sambhal district. Holi will be celebrated on Friday, March 14, coinciding with the Jumu’ah (Friday prayers) during Ramadan, a rare occurrence in the past 60 years. According to a report by NDTV on Wednesday, March […]

India Joins Elite Space Club with Successful Unmanned Space Docking

India has achieved a significant milestone in space exploration by becoming the fourth country after the US, Russia, and China to successfully execute an unmanned docking in space. The Space Docking Experiment (SpaDeX) saw two small spacecraft, each weighing approximately 220 kg, perform a docking maneuver in low-Earth orbit on Thursday, an event hailed as […]

Bangladesh Investment Summit: A Grand Spectacle with Hollow Out comes

Dr Abul Hasnat Milton The recently concluded Bangladesh Investment Summit, hyped for months by loyalists of the illegitimate Yunus regime, has ended with little to show for the extravagant promises that surrounded it. What was touted as a turning point for the country’s economic future has instead become a classic case of state-sponsored pageantry with […]

Kremlin Confirms Upcoming US-Russia Talks Amid Ongoing Ukraine Conflict

The Kremlin announced on March 20 that the next round of US-Russia talks could occur on March 23 or early next week, coinciding with planned discussions between Washington and Kyiv in Saudi Arabia. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov stated that the exact date is still under negotiation, suggesting the talks might begin at the start of […]

Pakistan Train Hostage Crisis: Rescue Operation Faces Challenges

Militants from the Baloch Liberation Army (BLA) hijacked a passenger train in Pakistan’s Balochistan province on Tuesday, taking hundreds of passengers hostage. The Pakistani military launched an immediate rescue operation, successfully freeing 155 hostages and killing 27 militants. However, the operation has become increasingly difficult as some militants have strapped suicide bombs to themselves and […]

Hugh Jackman Cancels Hyde Park Concert Due to Scheduling Conflict

Hugh Jackman has announced the cancellation of his much-awaited UK concert, which was set to take place at London’s Hyde Park on July 6, 2025. The decision comes due to an unforeseen scheduling conflict, leaving fans deeply disappointed. The X-Men star, who first revealed the special show in November 2024, shared the news via a […]