May 28, 2025 4:41 pm
Full News

Immigration Promises and Pitfalls: Why UK Leaders Struggle to Deliver on Migration Targets

For the past 15 years, UK leaders have made bold promises to control immigration, yet each one has ultimately failed to meet their goals. Sir Keir Starmer’s recent remarks at the Interpol conference emphasized a shift away from “gimmicks” and empty promises, as he aimed to tackle the issue of immigration by reducing both net migration and economic reliance on it.

This is not a new stance; similar promises have been made by Prime Ministers going back to David Cameron, who in 2010 vowed to reduce net migration to the “tens of thousands.” Despite these repeated pledges, migration numbers have consistently remained high, often exceeding 200,000, with significant spikes, including a rise to over 300,000 during the Brexit referendum period.

Boris Johnson, after winning the Brexit referendum, promised to take back control of immigration. His “Australian points-based system” replaced the target of reducing net migration, but despite these reforms, migration reached record highs during his tenure, peaking at over 700,000 by 2022. Even Rishi Sunak, while in office, promised to curb migration, suggesting that he might even introduce a cap on immigration if he won the 2024 election.

So why do these promises continue to fail?

David Cameron himself points to the unexpected economic and employment crises that began in 2012, which led to an influx of workers from across Europe. Others suggest that political dysfunction and competing departmental interests—such as the Home Office pushing for reduced numbers while the Treasury and Business departments seek more migrants to boost tax revenues and attract talent—have contributed to the failure.

Some critics argue that there is a deeper issue at play: a systemic bias in favour of large-scale immigration. Suella Braverman, former Home Secretary, cited opposition from other government ministers who believed that cutting immigration could harm the economy, particularly by reducing tax revenue. Likewise, former Immigration Minister Robert Jenrick described an unsettling conversation with Sunak, who suggested that mass migration helped lower inflation by undercutting wages.

But political forces alone don’t explain the challenge. The rise of Migration Watch in the early 2000s brought the focus of the immigration debate onto numbers, providing politicians with an “irresistible” way to frame the issue. Migration Watch, founded by Lord Green and Professor David Coleman, shifted the conversation away from race and ethnicity to one focused on the volume of migrants entering the UK.

This shift had lasting consequences, with political leaders from Michael Howard to David Cameron adopting numerical limits on immigration. Yet, as seen with Cameron’s pledge to reduce net migration to the “tens of thousands,” this focus on numbers has proven to be politically perilous and difficult to achieve in practice.

While some countries, like Switzerland, are experimenting with population caps, and the United States is considering deportation targets, questions persist about whether migration numbers are even the best measure of immigration success. Critics argue that the inclusion of temporary residents, like overseas students, skews the figures, and that focusing on numbers alone misses the broader question of how well migrants are integrated into society.

As for Sir Keir Starmer, while he has refrained from setting specific targets for migration reduction, his government will likely face the same pressures that have confronted past leaders—global crises, economic shifts, and unpredictable migration flows. The real question is whether, when faced with these challenges, Starmer will succeed where so many others have failed in managing migration numbers.

Related News
World Court Concludes Hearings on Legal Obligations to Combat Climate Change
Catholics in Indonesia’s Aceh Celebrate Muted Christmas Amid Islamic Law
NATO Boosts Presence in Baltic Sea Amid Suspected Sabotage of Undersea Infrastructure
State Department Press Briefing Highlights U.S. Stance on Bangladesh’s Human Rights and Judicial Integrity
Arab countries angry over ‘Greater Israel’ map
Finland’s President Urges France or Britain to Engage with Russia on Ukraine
Related Posts
Trump Promised ‘No Tax on Social Security’—But the GOP Tax Bill Falls Short
Continued Downtrend in Bangladesh Stock Market Sparks Investor Anxiety
Germany’s Chancellor Promises to Support Ukraine in Producing Long-Range Missiles
Trump’s 5-Step Strategy to Keep GOP Control of the House in 2026
Jakarta Emerges as France’s Leading Arms Client in Southeast Asians
Trump’s Fury with Putin Grows Amid Republican Rift Over Ukraine War
More News

Bangladesh All-Rounder Soumya Sarkar Ruled Out of Pakistan T20I Series

Bangladesh have suffered a major setback ahead of their upcoming T20 International (T20I) series against Pakistan, with all-rounder Soumya Sarkar ruled out due to a back injury.Soumya Sarkar’s Injury Update Sarkar, who also missed the recent T20I series against the UAE in Sharjah, has been experiencing discomfort in the right side of his lower back […]

IPL and PSL to Resume on Saturday

Both the Indian Premier League (IPL) and the Pakistan Super League (PSL), which were suspended due to India-Pakistan tensions, are set to resume on Saturday. The IPL, which was suspended on May 9 for a week, will resume with its remaining 17 matches played across six venues: Bengaluru, Jaipur, Delhi, Lucknow, Mumbai, and Ahmedabad. The […]

Medvedev Threatens Trump with World War III over Putin Criticism

The Voice News: Former Russian President and current Deputy Chairman of Russia’s highest security agency, the Russian Security Council, Dmitry Medvedev has threatened U.S. President Donald Trump with World War III for criticizing Russian President Vladimir Putin. In a post on social media platform X (formerly Twitter) on Tuesday, Medvedev said: “Trump recently said that […]

Philippines Protests China’s Deployment of ‘Monster Ship’ in EEZ

The Philippines has lodged a protest over the presence of the 165-meter-long Chinese coast guard vessel 5901, which was spotted 77 nautical miles off the coast of Zambales province. National Security Council spokesman Jonathan Malaya described the deployment as “alarming” and “clearly meant to intimidate fishermen operating around a contested shoal in the South China […]

US Department of Defence to Consider Granting Honourable Discharges to LGBTQ+ Veterans

January 7, 2025 – The US Department of Defence is set to consider granting honourable discharges to over 30,000 gay and bisexual veterans who were barred from military service due to their sexual orientation, according to legal filings on January 6. This move could make the veterans eligible for medical and other benefits. The department […]

Transforming Cancer Treatment: The Promise of Ultra-Fast Flash Therapy

In the quest to advance cancer treatment, a groundbreaking approach called Flash therapy is emerging from the laboratories of Cern, the European Organization for Nuclear Research, located just outside Geneva, Switzerland. This pioneering technology offers a radical departure from traditional radiotherapy, delivering radiation doses at ultra-high speeds with the potential to transform cancer care. The […]

U.S.-India Partnership Emphasized by Vance, Warns of a ‘Dark Era’ if It Fails

U.S. Vice President J.D. Vance has stated that the United States plans to expand trade with India in the energy and defense equipment sectors. During a speech in Jaipur, India on Tuesday, he emphasized that the partnership between the two nations will shape the course of this century, according to British news agency Reuters. Vance […]

The Pakistan Army Returns to Bangladesh in February: India Concerned Over Security

The Pakistan Army is set to return to Bangladesh in February 2025, marking the first time since it was expelled from what was then East Pakistan in 1971. This development raises significant security concerns for India. Amidst diplomatic tensions between India and Bangladesh following the ousting of the Sheikh Hasina government, the Pakistan military’s new […]

Heart Attack Risk Can Be Identified by Age 10: Findings from Harvard Pilgrim Healthcare Institute

Heart diseases often emerge suddenly. Even seemingly healthy individuals can suffer from unexpected heart attacks, sometimes without enough time for medical intervention, resulting in fatalities. A recent study by Harvard’s Pilgrim Healthcare Institute suggests that precautions against heart attacks can begin as early as childhood. According to the research, it is possible to predict by […]

Moana 2 Streams on Disney+ March 12

The highly anticipated sequel to Disney’s 2016 smash hit Moana has finally confirmed its release date on Disney+ after an extraordinary run in theaters. Following a massive box office success, Moana 2 earned over $1 billion globally, making it one of the biggest films of 2024. Disney has now revealed that the film will be […]