May 28, 2025 4:01 am
Full News

Does India hold a legitimate right to respond to Bangladesh’s perceived aggression ?

Aggression and Retaliation in South Asia: Bangladesh’s Threats, India’s Right to Respond, and Strategic Support from the U.S. and China

Dastagir jahangir


International law’s principles on aggression and retaliation exist to protect peace and stability between nations. Recently, South Asia witnessed heightened tensions following statements by Dr. Muhammad Yunus, Chief Adviser of Bangladesh’s interim government, during an interview with NDTV on August 6, 2024. India, which was crucial in supporting Bangladesh’s independence in 1971, was warned of potential destabilization in its northeastern regions, including West Bengal, seven sisters and neighboring Myanmar, if it were to interfere in Bangladesh’s internal affairs.


“If you destabilize Bangladesh, it will spill over all around Bangladesh, including Myanmar and seven sisters in West Bengal everywhere,” Dr. Yunus told NDTV. This article explores how such statements could be interpreted as aggression under international law, examines India’s right to respond under the law, and considers the supportive roles of the U.S. and China in addressing this rising tension.


Context of Dr. Yunus’ Statements


Under Dr. Yunus’ leadership, Bangladesh has been cautious about potential foreign interference in its affairs, particularly from India, which has been a long-standing supporter. Yunus’ remarks specifically threatened destabilization in India’s northeastern states—regions with historic ties and complex ethnic dynamics—as well as in Myanmar. His comments raised concerns that India’s engagement in Bangladesh’s internal issues could trigger a cross-border crisis, affecting West Bengal and even Myanmar.
These statements are particularly significant as they also implicate China’s strategic interests. China, like India, has substantial economic investments in Myanmar and aims to maintain regional stability to protect its assets. Beijing has interpreted the possibility of destabilization in Myanmar as a regional threat, aligning its interests with India’s stance on preserving stability in South Asia.
Defining Aggression and Yunus’ Comments Under International Law


According to UN General Assembly Resolution 3314, aggression includes the “threat or use of force against the sovereignty, territorial integrity or political independence of another State.” By this definition, a statement threatening destabilization within India’s borders, even indirectly, constitutes aggression. Yunus’ remarks to NDTV could be interpreted as crossing into this territory, given that they explicitly suggest repercussions extending to India’s internal stability, particularly in West Bengal and the northeastern region.


International law asserts that verbal threats of force, when credible and directed at another nation’s peace and security, can be considered an act of aggression. Dr. Yunus’ reference to West Bengal and the Seven Sisters region appears to violate norms that prohibit threats of aggression, suggesting that Bangladesh’s interim government may intend to disturb regional stability.
India’s Right to Lawful Retaliation
In cases of aggression, Article 51 of the

UN Charter provides nations the right to self-defense. Given Dr. Yunus’ statements, India could argue that its sovereignty and security are under threat, invoking Article 51 as justification for defensive measures, including diplomatic or strategic actions to counter the threat.
India’s actions, however, must adhere to the principles of proportionality and necessity under international law, focusing on measures that directly address the threat. Diplomatic or economic steps aimed at preserving regional stability could ensure that India’s response remains balanced and committed to peace.


Influence of U.S. President-Elect Donald Trump and Chinese Support


Geopolitical dynamics surrounding this issue have attracted attention from both the U.S. and China. President-elect Donald Trump has maintained a strong relationship with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, with his administration showing consistent support for India’s strategic concerns. This relationship enhances India’s international position and deters hostile actions from Bangladesh.
China, too, has an interest in maintaining stability in Myanmar, given its economic investments and regional influence. Any destabilization in Myanmar would threaten China’s strategic and economic projects, aligning its interests with India’s concerns. Beijing’s potential diplomatic support for India adds further strength to India’s stance, signaling that any actions jeopardizing regional peace could meet resistance from both powers.


Implications for Regional Stability and the Role of International Mediation


The escalating rhetoric between Bangladesh and India highlights South Asia’s sensitive geopolitical dynamics, where historical ties and shared borders necessitate peaceful relations. While India has a legitimate right to respond to Bangladesh’s perceived aggression, both nations could benefit from international mediation to avoid actions that may disrupt the region.


Organizations such as the United Nations may play a crucial role in mediating this dispute, promoting diplomatic engagement over retaliatory measures. The UN Security Council, for instance, could provide a platform for Bangladesh and India to resolve their grievances and maintain peace.

Conclusion: Navigating the Balance Between Rights and Peace


The statements made by Dr. Yunus have rekindled concerns about aggression and the right to lawful retaliation in South Asia. Under international law, India is within its rights to defend its sovereignty, though it must carefully navigate the situation to avoid unnecessary escalation. With potential support from both the U.S. and China, India holds significant diplomatic leverage, which could ease tensions through dialogue.


As South Asia confronts new security challenges, adherence to international law and diplomatic solutions remains the best course forward. Balancing national sovereignty with the pursuit of regional peace is essential for Bangladesh, India, and the broader international community focused on stability in South Asia.


Editor
The Voice News

Source : NDTV Interview / The economic Times

Related News
US Averts Shutdown as Senate Passes Budget Deal
Lower Prices Drive Surge in U.S. New Home Sales, but Outlook Remains Uncertain
UAE holds ‘secret’ talks on formation of post-war government in Gaza
US Envoy Sets “Red Line” for Iran Ahead of Nuclear Agreement Talks
Trump Administration Creates New System for Attending White House Press Briefings
Indian Billionaire Gautam Adani Indicted in $265 Million U.S. Bribery Scheme
Related Posts
How Trump Plans to Avoid a Third Impeachment
Apple Rejected Elon Musk’s Satellite Offer—Now Its Ambitious Plans Are in Jeopardy
Direct Talks Between Syria and Israel
U.S. Warns Pirelli of Potential Sales Restrictions Over Chinese Ownership and Data-Collecting Tire Technology
Ukraine’s Drone Motherships Launch Groundbreaking Long-Range Autonomous Strikes
Israeli Troops Fire as Aid Operation Collapses Amid Gaza Hunger Crisis
More News

U.S. Deports 31 Bangladeshi Nationals Amid Immigration Crackdown

Dhaka, April 21, 2025 — The United States has deported 31 Bangladeshi nationals as part of its intensified immigration enforcement policies. The group, comprising 30 men and one woman, was repatriated to Dhaka over recent weeks, with the latest batch arriving last Saturday on a chartered flight.   According to U.S. authorities, the deportees […]

South African HIV Vaccine Trials Halted Due to US Aid Cut Under Trump’s Administration

JOHANNESBURG – South African lab technician Nozipho Mlotshwa was eagerly awaiting test results for a potential HIV vaccine, a breakthrough that has eluded scientists for decades, when the order came from the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) to cease work. The initial round of vaccines produced an immune response in rabbits, offering promising […]

Fighting Fire and Stigma: California Inmates on the Frontlines

Nearly 1,000 incarcerated men and women are battling record-breaking wildfires in southern California, risking their lives as part of a volunteer program run by the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR). Currently, 939 inmates are deployed, marking a steady increase since the fires began spreading uncontrollably across Los Angeles. The wildfires have destroyed over […]

Stock Market Drops Amid Fears of Trump’s ‘Liberation Day’

U.S. President Donald Trump has announced that he will declare new tariffs on Wednesday, causing the stock market to decline in anticipation of his “Liberation Day.” The S&P 500 fell by 0.5%, while the Nasdaq dropped 1.4%. Clearly, investors are hesitant to take risks ahead of the tariff announcement. The price of gold has surged, […]

HRW Accuses Israel of Committing ‘Acts of Genocide’ by Cutting Off Water in Gaza

Human Rights Watch (HRW) has accused Israel of committing “acts of genocide” by deliberately obstructing access to water in Gaza. The organization’s 184-page report, released Thursday, claims that since Israel’s military offensive began in October 2023, it has systematically denied Palestinians in Gaza the clean water required for survival. HRW stated that Israel’s actions are […]

Sri Lankan President Assures PM Modi: Won’t Allow Land to Be Used Against India Amid Chinese Influence

NEW DELHI: Sri Lankan President Anura Kumara Dissanayake on Monday assured Prime Minister Narendra Modi that Sri Lanka would not permit its territory to be used in any manner harmful to India’s interests. The statement comes amid growing Chinese influence in the region, particularly through the strategic Hambantota Port. During discussions at Hyderabad House in […]

Russian Drone Attack on Bus in Ukraine’s Sumy Region Kills Nine, Hours After Peace Talks Begin

At least nine people were killed and seven others injured after a Russian drone struck a passenger bus in northeastern Ukraine, according to Ukrainian authorities. The deadly attack occurred just hours after Ukraine and Russia held their first direct peace talks in three years. Despite discussions covering potential leader-level meetings, a ceasefire, and a prisoner […]

“Commonwealth Women’s Day: 8 Inspirational Women Leading Global Change”

From saving lives under dire circumstances to breaking barriers in leadership, these eight exceptional women are making significant strides across the globe: 1. Safa Ali – A Lifesaver Amid Conflict in Sudan:When violent clashes erupted near her hospital, Dr. Safa Ali, a consultant in obstetrics and gynecology, remained steadfast in her mission. Operating from Al-Saudi […]

Over 6 Million in Los Angeles Face Severe Fire Risk as Strong Winds Continue

Los Angeles is currently enveloped in a dire situation as more than 6 million residents face an unprecedented fire risk, with forecasts predicting the continuation of strong Santa Ana winds through Wednesday. This meteorological phenomenon is intensifying the battle against several massive wildfires that have already wreaked havoc across the region. The Palisades Fire, which […]

Trump Calls for Jordan and Egypt to Accept More Palestinians Amid Gaza Crisis

WASHINGTON – On January 25, US President Donald Trump urged Jordan and Egypt to accept more Palestinians from Gaza, where Israel’s ongoing war against Hamas has created a severe humanitarian crisis. When asked if his suggestion was temporary or long-term, Trump responded, “Could be either.” In 2024, Washington had opposed the forcible displacement of Palestinians. […]