The Voice Report
A growing number of Democrats are calling on former President Joe Biden to take responsibility for the party’s loss to Donald Trump in the 2024 election, arguing that his decision to run for a second term contributed significantly to their defeat.
Democratic strategists, operatives, and donors expressed frustration in recent interviews and private messages, saying Biden’s insistence that he could have won — and his refusal to fully acknowledge his role in Vice President Kamala Harris’s loss — is preventing the party from moving forward.
“Would it be nice if Biden admitted he shouldn’t have run again? Sure,” said Anthony Coley, a former Biden administration official. “But at this point, history will judge — and the first draft isn’t favorable.”
Recent polling from the Associated Press-NORC Center shows optimism among Democrats has plummeted, with only one-third feeling hopeful about the party’s future — a sharp drop from July 2024.
Many Democrats now believe the party must overhaul its entire approach, from messaging and voter outreach to fundraising strategies. Outspending opponents no longer guarantees success, especially against Trump.
Critics are particularly frustrated with Biden’s post-election interviews, in which he defended his record and dismissed concerns about his cognitive decline. He attributed Harris’s defeat to sexism, adding that he wasn’t surprised by the outcome.
But party insiders say real accountability is needed. “He needs to stop blaming others and acknowledge that he let the party down by refusing to step aside,” said one Democratic strategist.
Former Obama adviser David Axelrod, a long-time critic of Biden’s reelection bid, reiterated his stance. “He should never have run again. The presidency is the toughest job on earth. Expecting an 81-year-old to campaign and serve another term was always unrealistic.”
Others, like former Obama aide Nayyera Haq, say Democrats are ready to move on. “There’s no longer a team protecting Biden’s ego,” Haq said. “It’s time to focus on what’s next.”
Despite the internal criticism, Biden’s closest allies remain supportive, and few expect them to change course now. But for the rest of the party, the path forward begins with honest reflection — starting at the top.