April 3, 2025 9:24 pm
Full News

Uncertainty over Chinmoy’s legal representation

With the bail hearing in a sedition case set for January 2, uncertainty looms over the legal representation of former ISKCON leader Chinmoy Krishna Das Brahmachari.The complications arose after a lawyer named Saiful Islam Alif was killed amid clashes between Chinmoy’s supporters and police in the court area when Chinmoy was denied bail on November 26. Saiful’s father later filed a murder case, while his brother started a case on charges related to explosives, attacks on justice-seekers and vandalism. Police also filed three cases and arrested dozens of people over the deadly violence. Bangladeshi the leading and influential English newspaper ‘The daily Star’ reveal an article regarding the issues. Here thevoice.news would like the news form the daily star.

Many of the nearly 60 counsels who had argued for Chinmoy during the hearing on November 26 have been made accused in the case filed by Saiful’s brother.

This Media outlet contacted six of these lawyers and another who stood for Chinmoy. They said that although there is no direct threat, they would not represent Chinmoy in court on January 2 since they came under attack on social media.

Chattogram District Bar Association said it asked its members not to defend the accused in the Saiful murder case, but there was no bar on them to represent the accused in any other case.It said lawyers from outside can still represent those accused in the Saiful murder case. The Bar also said no one filed any complaint over a threat, and action will be taken if such a complaint is filed.

Public Prosecutor Mafizul Haque Bhuiyan told yesterday that they will oppose Chinmoy’s bail if a lawyer files a petition for him. He said the court will then decide whether to grant Chinmoy legal aid.

Meanwhile, Chattogram Bar announced it would form a human chain on Wednesday demanding the arrest of the rest of the accused in Saiful murder case and the transfer of the case to a speedy trial tribunal.

Chinmoy alias Chandan Kumar Dhar, who is also the spokesperson for the Sammilita Sanatani Jagaran Jote, and 18 others were sued by a BNP leader on October 31 for allegedly disrespecting Bangladesh’s national flag during a Hindu community rally in Chattogram’s New Market area on October 25.

Police arrested him a month later, and the following day, he was produced before a Chattogram court that denied him bail and sent him to jail. At that time, his supporters burst into protests and clashed with law enforcers and lawyers outside the court. Lawyer Saiful was beaten up and hacked to death during the violence. According to court sources, lawyer Suvasish Sharma submitted a Vakalatnama for Chinmoy on November 26. A Vakalatnama is a document that authorises a lawyer to act on behalf of his/her client. Despite repeated attempts over several days, Suvasish could not be reached for confirmation if he would seek to represent Chinmoy again on January 2.

Since there was no lawyer to represent Chinmoy during the bail hearing on December 3, senior lawyer Rabindra Ghosh from Dhaka filed an application to advance the date for Chinmoy’s bail hearing. However, the court rejected the application due to the absence of a Vakalatnama on December 11.

Regan Acharjee, one of the lawyers accused in the case filed by Saiful’s brother, told that he and Saiful were very close. Regan alleged Regan was attacked by around 10 of his colleagues when he was with two of his clients in his chamber during the clashes. The attackers vandalised the chamber before the clients and other lawyers rescued him.

“I am physically unstable now and have mental trauma. I have also been named in an FIR [First Information Report] and received threats through Facebook posts and comments. All of these make me feel unsafe to go to the court,” said Regan. “Many of us have the same fear. If someone becomes a victim of mob justice, no one will want to come forward to save them. Our senior lawyers are handling our bail issues in consultation with the Bar,” he added.

On condition of anonymity, another lawyer who participated in Chinmoy’s bail hearing on November 26 said, “This is the first time we are facing something like this over Chinmoy’s issue. Lawyers fear being humiliated if they handle the case, so no one is coming forward.” Another lawyer who alleged threats via Facebook said the situation has affected their income.

However, many accused in Saiful’s brother’s case are still working in court. One of them, a senior lawyer, told the reporter of the media, “I was not at the scene during the clash, and I did not stand for Chinmoy in court, but I have been implicated in the case.”I have been coming to court and continuing my work. No one has threatened or obstructed me.”

Chattogram Bar’s IT Secretary Abhijit Ghosh is also an accused in the case. However, he has been working in the court. He said the bar association was looking into the issue of lawyers being implicated in the case filed by Saiful’s brother.

“Many have been named as accused in the case while performing their professional duties. It is natural to feel fear when someone is accused in a case.

“However, no one has informed us about feeling insecure. If anyone notifies the bar association, we will take action.” Bar President Nazim Uddin Chowdhury refuted allegations that Chinmoy’s lawyers were attacked on November 26.

“It’s the conspiracy of the Indian media to establish fascism in the country once again. It’s false news, and there was no such incident.”He said reports of Chinmoy’s lawyers feeling unsafe over threats were an “exaggeration by the Indian media to disrupt the peaceful environment”. “I have no information that someone was assaulted or threatened so far in Chinmoy’s incident. It’s true that some lawyers were made accused in a case, but I have seen several of them doing their regular work in the court. “If someone doesn’t show up, that’s their personal issue. I can’t force them to come.”

Nazim also said the Chattogram Bar requested its members not to defend the accused in Saiful murder case. “But I never said lawyers from outside couldn’t come here and participate in the case hearing. We also have no issues with the other cases.”

Rabindra Ghosh, the lawyer from Dhaka who sought to represent Chinmoy, said, “A member of the Bar, Sumit Acharya, had told me that he would sign a Vakalatnama in favour of me, but he later refused to do so following the pressure or threat from Bar leaders.”

According to Nazim, there is a rule that a lawyer from outside requires a Vakalatnama from a local lawyer to represent a client.

Sumit told this newspaper, “It’s true that lawyer Saiful’s murder pains all the advocates of Chattogram court. The incident triggered anger among everyone in the court. However, I did not face any physical threat or any other bullying.”

” I felt mental pressure, so I decided not to sign the Vakalatnama for Rabindra. No one asked me to do so,” he added.

Related News
National Human Rights Commission of  Bangladesh stepped down
Malaysia Faces Worst Flooding in a Decade: 3 Dead, Over 80,000 Displaced
North Korean Hackers Steal $1.3 Billion in Cryptocurrency in 2024
Dhanush Wins Big in Copyright Lawsuit Against Nayanthara
Exclusive Visa Program for World-Class Talent Launched
World Leaders React to Trump’s Tariff Imposition
Related Posts
Elon Musk to Step Down from Government Role
Elon Musk’s Cost-Cutting Team Sends Error-Ridden Termination Notices to USAID Staff
Finland’s President Urges France or Britain to Engage with Russia on Ukraine
Controversial Waqf Bill Passed in India’s Lok Sabha
Israeli Forces Used Palestinians as ‘Human Shields’
Trump’s ‘Liberation Day’ Tariffs Spark Economic and Political Risks
More News

Super Bowl Attendees Seek Suites for Views of Taylor Swift and Trump

As the highly anticipated Super Bowl in New Orleans approaches, fans are hoping to secure prime seating for an unforgettable view of two high-profile guests: pop sensation Taylor Swift and President Donald Trump. Both are confirmed to attend the game at Caesars Superdome on Sunday, February 9, 2025, but luxury hospitality experts, including Mike Zandman, […]

Hamilton Thrilled to Begin Ferrari Journey

Lewis Hamilton has expressed his excitement as he begins his new chapter with Ferrari in 2025. The seven-time Formula 1 world champion officially joined the iconic Italian team on January 1 and shared his thoughts on the move through a LinkedIn post. “I couldn’t be more excited,” Hamilton wrote, emphasizing his commitment to “embracing new […]

Haalnd penalty saved as Amn city held by Everton.

Erling Haaland had a second-half penalty saved by Jordan Pickford as Manchester City’s crisis continued with a laboured Premier League draw against Everton at Etihad Stadium.Pep Guardiola’s side, once all-conquering, are in unfamiliar territory amid a staggering fall-off, with just one win now in their past 13 games in all competitions.The result leaves the champions […]

US Navy Pilots Survive Red Sea Fighter Jet Downing in Apparent Misfire Incident

Two US Navy pilots safely ejected from their F/A-18 fighter jet on Saturday after it was mistakenly shot down over the Red Sea in an apparent friendly fire incident. According to US Central Command (CENTCOM), the aircraft was operating from the USS Harry S. Truman when it was unintentionally fired upon by the USS Gettysburg, […]

Hollywood Hills Engulfed as Los Angeles Faces Massive Wildfire Crisis

A terrifying wave of wildfires, described as “the big one,” has encroached upon Los Angeles, with a new blaze igniting in the Hollywood Hills, threatening the symbolic heart of the American film industry. The fires have pushed closer to Hollywood Boulevard and its iconic Walk of Fame, escalating fears of further destruction in this historic […]

South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol Faces Arrest as Warrant Deadline Looms

Seoul, South Korea – South Korean investigators are racing against time to arrest suspended President Yoon Suk Yeol, with less than 24 hours remaining before their warrant expires on January 6. The embattled leader remains holed up in his residence, surrounded by loyal security forces. Yoon, a former star prosecutor, has defiantly refused questioning three […]

Russia: “The Real Surprise is That Trump Didn’t Hit Zelensky

Russia has blamed Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky for the breakdown of his meeting with U.S. President Donald Trump, calling Zelensky’s behavior arrogant and provocative. In a statement on Telegram, Russian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maria Zakharova criticized Zelensky, saying, “Given Zelensky’s arrogance during the meeting, it is surprising that Trump showed restraint and did not resort […]

Ronaldo Tops the Earnings in 2024, Where is Messi?

Cristiano Ronaldo continues to be the highest-earning athlete in 2024, despite moving from top-tier European football to play in Saudi Arabia. His income remains substantial, securing his position as the world’s highest-paid sports figure. In the latest Forbes rankings, Ronaldo leads the list with an impressive 260 million USD in earnings. He has maintained this […]

Pope Francis to Meet Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas Amid Criticism of Gaza Conflict

VATICAN CITY – Pope Francis is set to meet Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas on Thursday, the Vatican announced, as the pontiff continues to voice strong concerns over Israel’s military actions in Gaza. Abbas is traveling to Italy this week, where he will also meet Italian President Sergio Mattarella and Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. The Vatican’s […]

Former U.S. Official Mike Benz Reveals Alleged White House Conspiracy in Ousting Sheikh Hasina

Former U.S. State Department official Mike Benz has made startling revelations to journalist Tucker Carlson, exposing a series of alleged plans and conspiracies involving the U.S. government and its impact on Bangladesh. Benz revealed plans for U.S. bases, military coups, color revolutions, and targeting of prominent figures like Sajeeb Wazed Joy. He also mentioned the […]